Free SEO audit for new clients — claim yours
Home/Blog/SEO/Striking Distance Keywords: Push Page-Two Rankin…
SEO

Striking Distance Keywords: Push Page-Two Rankings Onto Page One

Striking Distance Keywords: Push Page-Two Rankings Onto Page One
Table of contents
  1. What a striking distance keyword actually is (and why positions 8 to 20 are the sweet spot)
  2. Pulling page-two queries out of Search Console in about ten minutes
    1. Useful regex filters for finding commercial striking distance terms
  3. Scoring opportunities by impressions, intent and business value
    1. Worked example: three queries on a hypothetical accounting firm site
  4. On-page changes that move a page from position 12 to position 5
    1. Match the query wording where it naturally fits
    2. Answer the questions the top results answer, then one they do not
    3. Fix the snippet so the impressions you already get turn into clicks
    4. Make the page easier to use
  5. Internal links and anchor text as the quickest ranking lever
  6. When striking distance pages need more than a tweak
  7. Tracking results and knowing when to stop optimising a page
  8. Questions marketers ask about striking distance keywords
    1. How many striking distance keywords should I work on at once?
    2. How long does it take to see movement?
    3. Should I create a new page instead of improving the ranking one?
    4. Do I need a paid tool?
    5. Can striking distance work hurt rankings?
  9. Your first striking distance sprint this month
  10. Further reading on striking distance keywords
  11. Sources for this striking distance keywords guide

Open the Performance report in Search Console for almost any site that has been publishing for a year or more and you will find the same pattern: a long list of queries where the site already ranks, but on the lower half of page one or somewhere on page two. Those pages are indexed, Google already considers them relevant, and they are earning impressions. They are just not earning many clicks.

These are striking distance keywords. They are usually the cheapest traffic gains available to a business, because you are improving something that already works partly rather than building from zero. A new page needs to be crawled, indexed, understood and trusted before it ranks for anything. A page sitting at position 11 has already cleared most of those hurdles.

This guide shows how to pull these queries out of Search Console, score them so you work on the ones that can pay back, apply the on-page and internal-link changes that tend to move them, and decide when a page has had enough attention. It is written for owners and marketers who do the work themselves, with worked numbers you can copy into a spreadsheet.

What a striking distance keyword actually is (and why positions 8 to 20 are the sweet spot)

A striking distance keyword is a query your site already ranks for, close enough to the top results that a modest improvement could move it into a position that earns meaningful clicks. Definitions vary. Semrush's original On-Page Boot Camp article describes them as terms where a site sits on "page two, page three". Most practitioners today use a tighter window, roughly positions 8 to 20, for three reasons:

  • Position 8 to 10 is still page one but rarely seen. On many results pages, ads, a map pack, AI Overviews and "People also ask" push these listings well below the fold, especially on mobile.
  • Positions 11 to 20 are page two. Few searchers click through to page two, so impressions there are often from people scrolling a continuous mobile results feed or from rank-tracking tools, not real demand you are winning.
  • Beyond 20, the gap is usually structural. A page at position 35 normally needs a rewrite, a different format or more authority, not a tweak. That is a different project.

There is also a timing reason to care now. Click-through rates at the very top are under pressure from AI features. Ahrefs found that, for the same set of informational keywords, the position-one click-through rate fell from 7.3% in December 2023 to about 1.6% in December 2025 where an AI Overview was shown.

“As of December 2025, AI Overviews reduce the organic click-through rate for position one content by 58%.”

— Ahrefs, Update: AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 58%

That does not make striking distance work less useful. It changes which keywords deserve it. Commercial and local queries, where AI Overviews appear less often and searchers still want to compare providers, usually reward a move from position 12 to position 4 far more than an informational query does. The scoring model later in this guide builds that in.

Position bandTypical situationUsual fix sizeTreat as striking distance?
1–3Already winning; protect click shareSnippet and freshness workNo (see defending rankings)
4–7Visible, earning some clicksTitle, intent match, depthSometimes, for high-value queries
8–10Bottom of page one, often below the foldOn-page refinement, internal linksYes
11–20Page two, relevant but not preferredSection additions, links, intent alignmentYes
21–40Weak relevance or authority gapRewrite, new page, link buildingNo, plan separately

If a query is already in the top three, the job is different: you are protecting click share, not chasing position. That is covered in our guide to defending a first-place ranking when competitors close in.

Pulling page-two queries out of Search Console in about ten minutes

You can do this with paid tools, but Search Console is the better starting point because it shows your real impressions from Google rather than modelled estimates. If you are not familiar with the report, our walkthrough of the Search Console Performance report explains each tab.

One definition matters before you filter. Google's help page describes the chart-level figure as "the average position of the topmost result from your site", and at table level as "the average position in Search results for the specific URL or grouping dimension shown in the table row" (Search Console Help). Because it is an average across every impression, a query that shows at position 4 for some users and 18 for others can report as 11. Treat it as a direction, not a precise rank.

  1. Set the date range to the last 3 months. Twenty-eight days is too noisy for low-volume queries; 16 months mixes in pages that have since changed.
  2. Tick all four metrics (clicks, impressions, CTR, average position) so they appear as columns.
  3. Open the Queries tab and add a filter on Position: greater than 7.9. Search Console lets you filter metrics directly from the table's filter icon.
  4. Add a second metric filter: Position smaller than 20.1.
  5. Add an impressions floor, for example impressions greater than 100 over the three months. Adjust for site size: a local trades site might use 30; a large publisher might use 2,000.
  6. Exclude brand queries. Use the Query filter with "Doesn't match regex" and your brand variants, such as acme|acmee|acme plumbing. Brand terms rarely belong on this list. The Search Console regex guide has more patterns.
  7. Export to Google Sheets or CSV.
  8. Repeat with the Pages tab selected and the same filters, then use the query-plus-page view (click a page, then switch to Queries) for your top candidates so you know which URL ranks for which query.

Two limits are worth knowing. First, Search Console hides some queries for privacy reasons. Search Engine Roundtable reported on an Ahrefs study of 146,741 sites which found that Google "hid 46.08% of all query data" (Search Engine Roundtable, July 2022). Your list is a sample, not a census. Second, the interface caps what you can export from a single view, so large sites should pull data through the API or bulk export instead.

Useful regex filters for finding commercial striking distance terms

Once the export is in a sheet, filtering by modifiers quickly separates commercial opportunities from informational ones. In the Search Console query filter (Custom, regex), patterns like these help:

GoalExample regexWhat it surfaces
Buying intentprice|cost|quote|hire|near me|best|vsComparison and purchase queries
Question queries^(how|what|why|when|can|does|is) Informational queries likely to trigger AI Overviews
Long queries^(\S+\s){4,}\S+$Five words or more; specific, often easier to win
Local modifierslondon|croydon|bromley (your areas)Location queries for service pages

Scoring opportunities by impressions, intent and business value

A raw export can easily run to several hundred rows. Working through them in order of impressions is the most common mistake: it pushes informational queries with huge impression counts and little commercial value to the top. A simple scoring model fixes that.

Add four columns to your sheet:

  • Impressions (I): from the export.
  • Position gap (G): current average position minus 3. A page at 12 has a gap of 9; at 8 the gap is 5. Smaller gaps are easier.
  • Intent value (V): 3 for transactional or local service queries, 2 for comparison and commercial research, 1 for informational.
  • AI exposure (A): 1.0 if the results page has no AI Overview when you check it, 0.5 if it does.

Then use a score such as Score = (I × V × A) ÷ G. It is deliberately simple. The aim is to rank the list in a defensible order, not to predict traffic precisely.

Worked example: three queries on a hypothetical accounting firm site

The figures below are illustrative, not client data.

QueryImpressions (3 months)Avg. positionGapIntent valueAI exposureScore
how to file a self assessment late9,00011.28.210.5549
accountant for contractors leeds1,4009.66.631.0636
cloud accounting software comparison for small business2,60014.811.820.5220

Sorted by impressions, the self assessment query wins easily. Sorted by score, the local contractor query comes first, even with less than a sixth of the impressions, because it is commercial, closer to the top and less exposed to an AI answer. That is usually the right call: one extra enquiry from a contractor is worth more to the firm than hundreds of informational visits.

Before committing, open each shortlisted results page in a private window and record what you see. If the top results are all a different page type from yours, such as tools or category pages when you have a blog post, no on-page tweak will fix it. Move those into a separate "intent mismatch" list.

On-page changes that move a page from position 12 to position 5

When a page ranks on page two, Google has judged it relevant but not the best answer. The changes that tend to close that gap are specific. Work through them in this order, from cheapest to most effort.

Match the query wording where it naturally fits

Check whether the exact phrase, or a close variant, appears in the title tag, the H1, an H2 and the first 100 words. Pages often rank for a query because of one passing mention. If "accountant for contractors" appears only in the footer, an H2 such as "What an accountant for contractors handles that a general practice does not" sends a clearer signal and helps the reader. Our guides to writing title tags and heading structure go deeper.

Answer the questions the top results answer, then one they do not

List the subtopics covered by the top five results. If four of them explain fees, IR35 status and timelines and your page covers only fees, you have a gap. Add a section for each missing subtopic, then add one thing none of them offer, such as a worked example, a checklist or a comparison table. Google's own guidance asks whether content provides "insightful analysis or interesting information that is beyond the obvious" (Google Search Central).

Fix the snippet so the impressions you already get turn into clicks

Even before a page moves, a better title and meta description can lift the click-through rate at its current position. Look for queries where CTR is well below the site's average for that position band. Our article on improving organic CTR covers testing methods.

Make the page easier to use

Slow, cluttered pages with intrusive pop-ups rarely win close contests. Check mobile layout, load time and whether the answer appears quickly on screen. A table of contents for long pages and a clear summary near the top help both people and AI systems that extract passages.

Avoid the temptation to change everything at once. If you rewrite the title, restructure the page, add 1,500 words and change the URL in one go, you will not know what worked, and you risk losing the relevance that got the page to position 12.

Internal links are the change most within your control and among the fastest to take effect, because Google recrawls well-linked pages often. A page sitting on page two is frequently an orphan or near-orphan: linked only from a blog index and a sitemap.

“Good anchor text is descriptive, reasonably concise, and relevant to the page that it's on and to the page it links to.”

— Google Search Central, Link best practices for Google

A practical process:

  1. Search your own site with site:yourdomain.com "accountant for contractors" to find pages that mention the topic but do not link to the target page.
  2. In Search Console's Links report, check how many internal links the target page has compared with your strongest pages.
  3. Add three to five contextual links from relevant, well-trafficked pages. Put them in the body copy, not only in footers or sidebars.
  4. Vary the anchor text naturally around the topic, for example "contractor accounting", "accountants who work with contractors", "our contractor accounts service". Repeating the identical exact-match phrase from every page looks forced and helps no reader.
  5. Link from the target page to its parent hub or category, so the cluster is connected both ways.

On blogs, category structure affects how well related posts link to each other. If your archives are a mess, our guide to organising blog categories and tags is worth reading before you start adding links. For a full method, see internal linking for SEO.

When striking distance pages need more than a tweak

Some pages will not move however well you optimise them. The usual reasons, and what to do about each, are below.

SymptomLikely causeResponse
Two of your URLs alternate for the same queryCannibalisationMerge into one page and redirect, or clearly separate their topics
Top results are all large brands with strong link profilesAuthority gapEarn links to the page or target a narrower variant
Top results are a different format (tool, category, video)Intent mismatchBuild the right page type rather than editing the article
Position swings by 10+ places week to weekGoogle testing; unstable SERPWait 4–6 weeks before judging changes
Forums and thin pages in the top tenWeak results pageA strong focused page can win; see weak spots

That last row is an opportunity rather than a problem. Our guide to finding SERP weak spots explains how to tell when a page-two ranking is up against beatable competition.

Tracking results and knowing when to stop optimising a page

Log every change with the date, the URL and exactly what changed. A simple sheet works: URL, target query, baseline position, baseline clicks per week, change made, date. Then compare like for like:

  • Use Search Console's compare mode for 28 days before against 28 days after, starting the "after" window a week after the change was crawled.
  • Filter to the specific page and query, not the whole site, so seasonal swings elsewhere do not mislead you.
  • Watch clicks as the primary metric. Position can improve while clicks stay flat if the results page is crowded with features.
  • Use a rank tracker for daily positions on your shortlist; Search Console's averages smooth out short-term movement. Our rank tracking guide explains setup.

Stop working on a page when one of these is true: it has reached positions 1 to 3 and clicks have plateaued; it has had two rounds of changes over three months with no movement, which points to an authority or intent issue that on-page work will not solve; or the business value has changed, for example the service is no longer offered.

Then go back to the export. Striking distance work is a cycle, not a one-off. Running the same Search Console filters each quarter will surface new candidates as fresh content matures and older pages slip.

Questions marketers ask about striking distance keywords

How many striking distance keywords should I work on at once?

For a small team, five to ten pages per month is manageable. That allows time to make careful changes, request indexing and measure each change rather than guessing.

How long does it take to see movement?

Internal link and on-page changes can show up within a few weeks once Google recrawls the page. Give each round at least four to six weeks before deciding it has failed.

Should I create a new page instead of improving the ranking one?

Usually not. The existing page already has relevance and history. Create a new page only if the query has a clearly different intent from the existing page's main topic.

Do I need a paid tool?

No. Search Console is enough to find and track opportunities. Paid tools help with competitor gaps and with queries Search Console anonymises, but they are optional.

Can striking distance work hurt rankings?

It can if you over-optimise, for example stuffing the exact phrase into every heading, or change too much at once. Make focused edits and keep the page useful to readers.

Your first striking distance sprint this month

Block out an afternoon. Pull the last three months of queries at positions 8 to 20, strip out brand terms, score the rest with the impressions, intent and AI exposure model above, and pick the top five. For each, fix the title and headings, add one missing section and three internal links. Log the changes and check back in six weeks.

If you would rather have a team do the analysis and the edits, our on-page optimisation service and wider SEO service start with exactly this kind of audit. Get a quote and tell us which pages you want to move first, or request a custom quote for an ongoing programme. You may also want to check what people see when they search your name, which is covered in our guide to managing your brand SERP.

Further reading on striking distance keywords

Sources for this striking distance keywords guide

  1. Semrush: On-Page Boot Camp: How To Identify Striking Distance Keywords
  2. Search Console Help: Performance report (Search results)
  3. Search Console Help: Performance report dimensions and data groupings
  4. Search Engine Roundtable: Google Search Console anonymizes tons of queries
  5. Ahrefs: Update: AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 58%
  6. Google Search Central: Link best practices for Google
  7. Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
Rohit Choudhary
Written byRohit ChoudharyCo-Founder, My SEO Experts

Rohit Choudhary is the co-founder of My SEO Experts and has more than 14 years of hands-on experience in SEO, paid advertising and digital marketing. Since starting out in 2011 he has helped hundreds of businesses grow through practical, data-driven search strategies, and he also serves as a consulting Digital Marketing Director for several US-based companies.

Keep reading

Related articles

Ready to grow your business online?

Get a free, no-obligation proposal tailored to your goals and budget.

CallFree Quote